An Assault at Mass

On 23 August, during Sunday Mass at the Cathedral of SS. Peter and Paul in Philadelphia, a lector was assaulted.  She had concluded the reading from Isaiah 22 and was making her way back to her seat when another woman approached her and threw two quick punches at her face.  As the assailant then walked away, the lector resumed walking to her seat.  Archbishop Nelson Pérez later issued a statement indicating that the lector had received medical attention and was not seriously injured.  Police in Philadelphia say that they have identified the assailant; for the moment, at least, charges have been deferred.

Does the assailant have mental health issues?  Drug problems?  Both?  Neither?  Have overwhelmed social service systems been unable to assist her?  Has she refused help that was offered to her?  Is she a person who just had a moment of (misdirected) rage?  As I write these words, we do not know.

[Since I began writing this post, it has emerged that the assailant does indeed have mental health issues.  According to the Philadelphia Inquirer, the district attorney and the Archdiocese of Philadelphia have determined that no charges will be filed.]

Whatever the case may be, I cannot help seeing in this incident a liturgical snapshot of the polarization, unrest, and violence simmering in the United States—and in all too many places, more than simmering.  At the same time, I see a person who was struck twice without provocation and who absorbed the blows without a hint of retaliation.  For present purposes, I will leave to moral theologians questions about when and what kind of self-defense is morally permissible.  I simply want to note the witness provided by this lector, a witness that demonstrates that striking back is not necessarily the only option.

Violence of this kind is always abhorrent.  I do not want to claim that it is “especially” abhorrent given the liturgical circumstances.  Violence is no less violent when it takes place in a bedroom, a kitchen, a workplace, or a town park.  I do wonder, though, about the impact of this incident on worshipers who, a few minutes later, heard “this is my body, which will be given up for you.”  I wonder how worshipers experienced the subsequent (contactless) exchange of peace.

Whether women should be admitted to ordained priesthood is a question for another time.  However, I think it is safe to say that this woman who just read from Isaiah proclaimed the gospel as she returned to her seat.  What does her example mean for how we proclaim the gospel in our conduct at liturgy—and outside of liturgy?






7 responses to “An Assault at Mass”

  1. William Fredereick deHaas Avatar
    William Fredereick deHaas

    No charges – why? This person needs to be overseen and receive pysch evaluation and treatment – the DA may need to order this???

    1. Timothy Brunk Avatar
      Timothy Brunk

      Since the woman is mentally ill, the case will be handled through the mental health system and not the criminal justice system. There are times when persons with mental illness are indeed culpable for legal offenses and hence should be processed through the criminal justice system (with mental health services as indicated). There are other times when the most appropriate response is mental health services without involvement of the criminal justice system. I do not know the particulars of this case but I assume that those involved are acting on what they know.

      1. Tom Zwick Avatar
        Tom Zwick

        It’s a beautiful example of compassion to help the aggressor. There is a spectrum of mental illness and anyone can have a mental lapse.
        Everyone has become to quick to jump to an eye for an eye response.
        Thanks Tim

      2. William Fredereick deHaas Avatar
        William Fredereick deHaas

        Thank you – guess it depends upon the state you live in and its laws governing this. Often we had to go to a mental health court (part of the legal system) to order a patient into treatment via commitment procedure (that is what I meant by referring to a criminal system)

  2. Jean-Paul Marie Justin Auman Avatar
    Jean-Paul Marie Justin Auman

    A question posed by Daniel Hunter during Campaign Nonviolence Conference held August, 2020 (Anniversary of Hiroshima/Nagasaki ).
    “How do we get ahead of the emotional state that causes people to go
    into violence?” rather than focus on how to respond once it expressed as violence.
    Blessed are the Peacemakers, for they will be called the Children of God.

  3. Michael H Marchal Avatar
    Michael H Marchal

    This is what the phrase Defund the Police is trying to get at.

  4. Donna Zuroweste Avatar
    Donna Zuroweste


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *