Field Report: Mass at the Church of the Holy Sepulcher

Edicule
While traveling in Jordan and Israel last week, I had the opportunity to attend Mass on the Solemnity of the Assumption at the Church of the Holy Sepulcher. The location and liturgy seemed unusual enough to warrant a “field report” for PrayTell readers.

The Mass was the daily “Solemn Mass” (as the Custodia Terrae Sanctae website calls it) that is celebrated each day (6:30 am in the winter and 7:30 am in the summer, because the various Christian communities that share use of the church cannot agree on whether they should observe daylight saving time). It was celebrated at the Edicule—the small stone structure enclosing the sepulcher itself (see the picture above). In addition to the presider, there were four or so concelebrants who also served as the schola, and a server who doubled as lector. There were about thirty people in attendance.

The entire Mass was sung in Latin, with the exception of the confiteor, the Suscipiat, and the Ecce Agnus Dei, which were said in Latin, and the homily, which was given in Italian (very slowly and clearly, so that between my knowledge of Latin, French, and Spanish I was able to follow the basic points). The choice of Latin was clearly motivated by the fact that there is no way to know the composition of the assembly ahead of time so Latin is probably the best default for having some participation. The assembly made a pretty good effort in singing the “Et cum spiritu tuo,” the “amens,” and the “Pater Noster.” The Gospel Acclamation (the familiar triple alleluia from the Easter Vigilย communio) got the most enthusiastic participation.ย Kyriales were provided, but we were never told which Mass we were using and I couldn’t figure it out until the Sanctus (Mass IX, which I probably should have guessed), so it was pretty much the schola alone that sang the ordinary.

The challenges posed byย the space were striking. We sat on benches in front of the Edicule, so the altar—the slab of the tomb—was closed off to our view (at said Masses with very small congregations, people apparently are invited to stand within the Edicule itself). During the introit, the celebrant and server went into the Edicule to cense the altar and then came out to conduct the liturgy of the word from a lectern placed in front the of Edicule. Then at the offertory the celebrant moved into the Edicule for the liturgy of the Eucharist (the concelebrants joined him after the Sanctus). Fortunately, because the entire Eucharistic Prayer was sung, it was quite audible (the few things were said we not very audible). The celebrant emerged for the Ecce Agnus Dei and then went back in for his and the other celebrants’ communion. Of course, the invisibility of the celebrant might seem quite normal to an Eastern Christian, but I was struck by how much the Latin Rite, at least since the Middle Ages, hasย presumed the visibility of the celebrant (whichever way he happens to be facing), and how strange it was to have the sense of sight removed from the equation.

There were a few other points worth noting:

  • The lector sang the two lessons and the celebrant sang the gospel (all in Latin), which I actually found made them easier to follow, since it slowed things down and required clear articulation.
  • The responsorial psalm, including the response, was sung to a psalm tone, which would have made it very easy to join in, if we had been given the words.
  • There was no Prayer of the Faithful; we moved straight from the creed to the preparation of the gifts.
  • Eucharistic Prayer II was used, so this was no attempt to mimic the Tridentine Mass.
  • Communion was given by intinction, which seems pretty common in the Latin Rite in the Middle East.
Fritz Bauerschmidt

I am a professor of Theology at Loyola University Maryland and a permanent deacon of the Archdiocese of Baltimore, assigned to the Cathedral of Mary Our Queen.

Please leave a reply.

Comments

7 responses to “Field Report: Mass at the Church of the Holy Sepulcher”

  1. Joshua Vas

    They might not be mimicking the Tridentine Mass but the Custody – especially at the Sepulchre – preserves some very curious ceremonial remnants of Tridentine praxis (whether this is conservatism due to the external constraints, or some other reason I don’t know). For example, all of the Franciscans incense the altar in the complicated “Tridentine” manner. Frequently the altar is prepared during the singing of the Creed (though this could be for reason of time) – this is noticeable on the Fridays when they celebrate at one of the Latin altars on Calvary. Sometimes (which is not often) if deacons assist, you’ll find some Tridentine configurations. Strangely, however, they have the practice of turning around to “show” the host to the people at the elevations, when they celebrate facing away from the people.

    It is not only restricted to the Mass – in the praying of the Office, and even the hearing of confessions one can find evidence of the older rites. I was once absolved in the vernacular using what was clearly a modified translation of the older rites. The Sepulchre is also the only place where I have witnessed Benediction with a ciborium.

    1. Daniel Canaris

      @Joshua Vas:
      I thought Benediction with a ciborium was standard practice on less festive occasions as the ceremonial is less complicated (i.e. no incense required)

  2. Ed Nash

    Thank you Fritz for this play by play in a sacred space that carries with it so many traditions on so many levels. In our parish we argue about the placement of candles…a much younger parish though.

  3. Chip Stalter

    Attending several liturgies (including one within the Edicule) was the highlight of a recent pilgrimage to the Holy Land. Watching the synchronization of the Orthodox, and Latin rites, with the Franciscans on the scene, as if they were traffic cops is quite a spectacle.

    A tip for any who visit, get up early- the doors to the building open at 4:30 am, and there are no crowds. It’s the most spiritual time to be there.

  4. Alexander Larkin

    On my last pilgrimage I con celebrated with another priest from our group at the Franciscan Mass. The deacon in our group proclaimed the Gospel. I told him: does it get any better than this for a deacon, to proclaim the Gospel of the resurrection at the tomb of Jesus!

  5. Todd Orbitz

    Having lived in the Sinai, as a longer term member of the MFO, and being able to freely travel between there and Israel on an Official Passport, I frequently attended Mass at the Sepuchre. I asked about some of the liturgical practices, which are evidently regulated in some way by the Custodians as a result of the agreement from centuries ago.

    The sense I got was that they would have to maintain some things involuntarilly, simply because they could not upset the other 16 Churches.

    1. Karl Liam Saur

      @Todd Orbitz:
      Like having the Easter Vigil on Saturday morning.


Posted

in

,

by

Tags:

Discover more from Home

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading