Papal Bull: Who Writes This Stuff?

by Michael Silhavy

I had the pleasure of being in Holy Name Cathedral for the installation of Blase Cupich as the ninth archbishop of Chicago. For me, one of the most anticipated moments of the liturgy was the readingย of the apostolic mandate, or the papal bull, announcing the appointment.ย Here’s theย full text:

To Our Venerable Brother, Blase Joseph Cupich, until now Bishop of Spokane, at this time appointed Metropolitan Archbishop of Chicago, greetings and Apostolic blessing.

When Our Venerable Brother Francis Eugene George, Cardinal of the Holy Roman Church, resigned from his archepiscopal office after an extensive, steadfast, and diligent ministry, it was without delay that We hastened to assign a new Shepherd to that celebrated โ€œCity of Broad Shoulders,โ€ which from the very beginning has been strong in its Catholic faith and also known for its hardworking citizens. Indeed, needless to say, it is only fitting that the See of Chicago be governed by a faithful and watchful servant, since it is Our desire that this ecclesial community, both old and new, continue henceforth to flourish, to blossom and to grow. For this reason, Venerable Brother, We turn our attention to you, who for some time now have labored zealously for the Flock in Spokane, and We judge you to have the requisite virtues of mind and character, by which you can carry out the governance of the Church in the โ€œWindy City.โ€

Therefore, upon consultation with the Congregation for Bishops, by virtue of the fullness of Our Apostolic authority, We release you from the bond of the Church of Spokane, and We choose and appoint you Metropolitan Archbishop of Chicago, with the obligations and the rights prescribed in canon law. In addition, We mandate that both the clergy and the people of your Local Church be informed about this Our decree and decision, and that they warmly welcome you as their Shepherd and guardian of truth.

Finally, Venerable Brother, as you travel east and embrace the people being entrusted to you in the State of Illinois, do not forget that the Lord, Who became our peace, had wished to set the earth on fire spiritually, so that, reconciling everything on earth and in the heavens through His cross, He might distinguish the true from the false, sift the wheat from the darnel, separate the evil from the good, longing to seek out whatever is lost and to bring it to salvation.

Given at Rome, at St. Peterโ€™s, on the twentieth day of the month of September, in the year of the Lord two thousand fourteen, the second of Our Pontificate.

Pope Francis

 

Rather than focusing on any message or admonition in the mandate, I found myself delighting inย its language. Someone really did their homework and had a good time writing this thing.

The fun began with working in the phrase “City of Broad Shoulders.” Carl Sandburg would have been proud. Chicagoans would haveย beamed with prideย over the phrase “hardworking citizens”;ย it’s aย descriptor residents are happy to claim as one of their attributes.

Perhaps the reference to city’s strong Catholic faith “from the very beginning” is due to theย missionary activity ofย Pere Marquette, acknowledged as one of the city’sย “discovers.”ย And, by the way, heย just happened to be a Jesuit.

The term “Windy City” was also used, and that one got a modest chuckle from those in attendance.ย That’s a term you just don’t expect to hear in a Vatican document. (I am thankful the Vaticanย language police did not try to correct that one.)

Francis expressed his wishes that the local church of Chicago continue to “blossom and grow.” That’s innocuous enough language, and perhaps there’s no cleverness as in the examples above, but it is a wonderful image for a city whose motto is Urbus en horto: a city in a garden.

The phrase “travel east” was a nice nod to Spokane and the phrase “set the earth on fire” was also quite clever. Was it a reference to the great Chicago Fire of 1871?

Half of the archdiocesan crest is given over to a depiction of a phoenix in recognition of the city that rose from the ashes. Was the fire image a nodย to St. Blase? Cupich’s coat or arms contains twoย burning candles in honor of his name sake. And then there’s the thought thatย the writerย is playing uponย the Blase/blaze homophone.

Perhaps readers may want to write in with their own examples of clever languageย from other installations. And perhaps someone can answerย the question, Who is tasked with writing these mandates?ย This one wasย well thought out if not outright playful.

Michael Silhavy is Assistant Senior Editor at GIA Publications, Inc. He is a graduate of Saint John’s University School of Theology-Seminary.

Other Voices

Please leave a reply.

Comments

11 responses to “Papal Bull: Who Writes This Stuff?”

  1. Scott Knitter

    I think Sandburg wrote that it’s a city of big shoulders, not broad. “City of the Big Shoulders…”
    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chicago_%28poem%29#mediaviewer/File:Hog_butcher_for_the_world.jpg

  2. Rita Ferrone Avatar
    Rita Ferrone

    This is amazing. I am so edified by this! I never knew an appointment could be written so thoughtfully or with such art.

    Here’s a pure speculation. Is the official bull written in Latin? Many of the expressions are felicitous in Latin. If so, could Reginald Foster be involved? He’s in retirement in Milwaukee, so just up the road. I’m not saying he composed it of course, but he’s someone who has the imagination required to write something both simple and wonderful. (If it’s a Latin-into-English situation, that could also account for Scott’s note about “big” turning into “broad.”)

    Or perhaps there is a poet in the presbyterate of the Church of Chicago…? Someone with a gift for language and knowledge of the locale put this together. Bravo.

  3. Philip Sandstrom

    Yes this is a fine document, but does no one notice the English translation changes ‘elect’ to ‘appoint’? This is the huge ecclesiological change which caused Bismark to write his famous letter to Pope Pius IX after Vatican I inquiring whether the local Bishops were now the ‘branch managers of the Pope’? In fact think I remember (without looking it) Bismark was even more incisive — inquiring whether the Bishops were now the mere ‘Postmen’ for the Pope? This note from Bismark produced a denial from Pope Pius IX and a further letter from the German Bishops duly noted in Denzinger et al. But the change from ‘elect’ to ‘appoint’ is significant ecclesiologically, and I think, ecumenically too.

  4. Fr. Ron Krisman

    “We release you from the bond of the Church of Spokane.”

    Another instance of the “Petrine privilege”?

    More seriously, I very much like the Patristic reference to a bishop being wedded to his local Church.

    1. Karl Liam Saur

      @Fr. Ron Krisman – comment #4:
      Well, otherwise he might not be able to receive Communion….

  5. Brian Duffy

    There are several excellent Latinists in the Vatican amongst whom is the distinguished American, Fr. Dan Gallagher. He is a man of such brilliance but with his fingers to the pulse of the people that he could very well have produced that mandate.

    Reggie used to thrill us with his stories about how Vatican documents were ironed out. Once an assistant used a word to which others took exception, but Reggie proved that Plautus used it.

    Such fun! At least from the point of view of a Latin teacher.

  6. George Jones

    This post made me smile. Thanks for bringing this bull to our attention!

  7. Andy Varga

    Well done, Michael!

  8. Jim McKay

    Scott Knitter : I think Sandburg wrote that itโ€™s a city of big shoulders, not broad. โ€œCity of the Big Shouldersโ€ฆโ€ http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chicago_%28poem%29#mediaviewer/File:Hog_butcher_for_the_world.jpg

    While Sandburg coined “city of big shoulders”, city of broad shoulders has been used to describe Chicago for quite a while. It is probably accidental substitution, since no one really says big shoulders much.

    But earlier this year, a City of Broad Shoulders event was held to celebrate Chicago, so that version of the quote may have still been ringing in the writer’s mind.

  9. Tom Cademartrie

    FYI, Cardinal Bernardin in the mid-1980’s initiated the Big Shoulders Fund for inner city schools. It’s still going strong. A website is easy to find.

  10. Chris McDonnell

    Vox Clara got nowhere near this one, thank goodness.
    Celebrate the scribe, he deserves it


Posted

in

,

by

Discover more from Home

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading