Check out the Tablet‘s editorial on a less than smooth transition to the new Missal translation in Scotland.
Living with the Missal in Scotland
Comments
4 responses to “Living with the Missal in Scotland”
-
Scotland is only mentioned in the article because the Tablet happens to have got a quote from the recently retired bishop of Aberdeen. I see no evidence that the introduction of the new missal is proving any more problematic here than elsewhere.
-
A strange editorial indeed. I agree with Ben…what exactly has this to do with Scotland, or anywhere else for that matter? It is simply a restatement of a position that has been expressed again and again in the Tablet.
They think the new translation is a “flawed product”. From there, they extrude a number of positions which are only sensible if you also think that the new translation is a flawed product. And then this somehow ends up being a rationale for claiming that Catholics want to see more collegiality.
There’s nothing incorrect said here, insofar as opinion can be neither “correct” nor “incorrect”, but is simply opinion.
-
Give me a V
Give me an O
Give me an X
Give me a C
Give me an L
Give me an A
Give me an R
Give me an AWhaddaya got?
At least it’s better than ’73!
YAY!!!! (while shaking pompoms vigorously over head)
-
Things like this give me a perverse hope. As in, this awkward misconstruction isn’t REALLY going to be workable in the long run, is it?
by
Tags:
Please leave a reply.